SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.14 issue1Editing and updating the magazine. A constant dynamicIn vitro antihypertensive activity by bioactive components of Andean grains author indexsubject indexarticles search
Home Pagealphabetic serial listing  

Services on Demand

Journal

Article

Indicators

Related links

Share


Journal of the Selva Andina Research Society

Print version ISSN 2072-9294On-line version ISSN 2072-9308

J. Selva Andina Res. Soc. vol.14 no.1 La Paz  2023  Epub Mar 31, 2023

https://doi.org/10.36610/j.jsars.2023.140100003 

ARTÍCULO ORIGINAL

Actualization List of species of the genus Tityus (Scorpionida: Buthidae) (Koch, 1843) in Bolivia

Humboldt-Paputsachis Ciro1  * 
http://orcid.org/0000-0003-3765-5169

1Ministry of Health and Sports. National Institute of Health Laboratories "Néstor Morales Villazón" INLASA. Immunoglobulin Production Laboratory. La Paz-Plurinational State of Bolivia. Rafael Zubieta Nº 1889, Miraflores. La Paz-Plurinational State of Bolivia. Casilla M-10019. Tel: +519 2 2226670.


Resumen

Los escorpiones del genero Tityus son un grupo ampliamente distribuido a lo largo del mundo teniendo mayor riqueza y diversidad en Sudamérica, estos son de importancia medica en la región sin embargo han sido poco estudiados en Bolivia. Se realizó una revisión de los ejemplares del Laboratorio de Producción de Inmunoglobulinas de INLASA, mediante el uso de diferentes claves dicotómicas del genero provenientes de Latinoamérica, así como el estudio de las descripciones originales de algunas especies descritas para Bolivia. Se presenta una lista actualizada de las especies de Tityus de Bolivia se mencionan 9 especies con sus respectivas localidades: T argentinus (Villa Tunari y Chapare en Cochabamba, Buena Vista y Campeche en Santa Cruz y en el Chaco de Chuquisaca), T. birabeni (Villa Tunari, Cochabamba), T. bolivianus (Tipuani, La Paz), T. confluens (Villa Montes, Tarija), T. horacioi (San Mateo, Cochabamba), T. kaderkai (Rurrenabaque y San Joaquín, Beni), T. proseni (Locotal, Cochabamba), T. sorataensis (Sorata, Cheje y Quime, La Paz) y se confirma la presencia de T. metuendus para Bolivia en el departamento de Pando. De esta forma, se actualizó el número de especies de Tityus para el territorio boliviano, como la distribución de T. metuendus.

Palabras clave: Bolivia; distribución; lista de especies; metuendus; Pando; Tityus

Abstract

The scorpions of the genus Tityus are a group widely distributed throughout the world, having greater richness and diversity in South America, they are of medical importance in the region, however they have been little studied in Bolivia. A review of the specimens of the Immunoglobulin Production Laboratory of INLASA was carried out, using different dichotomous keys of the genus from Latin America, as well as the study of the original descriptions of some species described for Bolivia. An updated list of Tityus species from Bolivia is presented, 9 species are mentioned with their respective localities: T argentinus (Villa Tunari and Chapare in Cochabamba, Buena Vista and Campeche in Santa Cruz and in the Chaco of Chuquisaca), T. birabeni (Villa Tunari, Cochabamba), T. bolivianus (Tipuani, La Paz), T. confluens (Villa Montes, Tarija), T. horacioi (San Mateo, Cochabamba), T. kaderkai (Rurrenabaque and San Joaquín, Beni), T. proseni (Locotal, Cochabamba), T. sorataensis (Sorata, Cheje and Quime, La Paz) and the presence of T. metuendus is confirmed for Bolivia in the department of Pando. Thus, the number of Tityus species for the Bolivian territory was updated, as well as the distribution of T. metuendus.

Keywords: Bolivia; distribution; list of species; metuendus; Pando; Tityus

Introduction

Scorpions are arthropods widely distributed in tropical, subtropical and desert areas of the world. In recent decades they have proliferated in urban and intra-domiciliary environments, some examples of which have occurred in Brazil and Argentina1-4. Regarding the colonization of urban environments, there is no information available for Bolivia.

Of the 22 families of scorpions, Buthidae is the most diversified on the planet and the only one that contains species potentially dangerous to humans5-7. The family Buthidae is distributed throughout the world with the exception of New Zealand and the poles.

The family has 80 genera and 972 described species2,4,8,9. One of the most important genera of Buthidae is the genus Tityus C. L. Koch 1836. L. Koch 1836, which has 204 species10 distributed in Central and South America, with greater richness and diversity in the latter.

Studies of the genus in Bolivia began with the description of T. bolivianusKraepelin (1895) and of the Bolivianus Complex by Kraepelin11. Subsequently 12,13 he added two new species T. proseni and T. birabeni respectively. In 1985, Lourenço & Maury14 in their work on the Bolivianus Complex cited 3 species belonging to this complex T. argentinus, T. bolivianus and T. sorataensis. Later Acosta & Ochoa15 listed the Bolivian scorpions, citing 8 of the genus Tityus for the region. In the same year16 they refuted the presence of T. gasci and T. metuendus for Bolivia, reducing the list to 6 species.

In 2005 Kovařík17 described T. kaderkai, the following year Lourenço10 proposed dividing the genus Tityus into 5 subgenera where he dispersed the Bolivian species into the subgenera Archaeotityus, Atreus and Tityus. The last species described for Bolivia in 2011 was T. horacioi by Lourenço & Leguin18 with a total of 8 species.

Bolivia has very little information related to scorpion diversity, most of the references come from original descriptions, being most of them very old. It should also be noted that, in many cases, since the original description, no collections of new individuals have been made to strengthen taxonomic knowledge of these species. In addition, knowing the number of Bolivian species will allow the development of research in other fields, such as biochemical and ecological medicine, given that the taxonomic identity of the species is always required, and future studies on Bolivian species could provide a glimpse of the lethality of the species.

The aim of this research was to present an updated list of the scorpions of the genus Tityus for Bolivia. Additionally, to confirm the presence of Tityus metuendus for the Bolivian territory by the presence of an individual in the scientific collection of the Laboratory of Immunoglobulin Production (LPI) of the National Institute of Health Laboratories (INLASA).

Materials and methods

For the elaboration of the list, all the works on the genus in the country were reviewed, as well as the original descriptions of some specimens and articles related to the taxonomy of the genus Tityus.

Specimens from the INLASA LPI collection were used. Specimens from the INLASA collection were reviewed with the parameters of the dichotomous keys of scorpions from several South American countries, such as Peru19, Venezuela20, Argentina21, Uruguay22 and Brazil2,15, as well as the original descriptions of some species12,13,23. The specimens from INLASA's wet collection were preserved in 70 % alcohol in glass jars according to the size of the individual, covered with rubber stoppers or screw caps for larger specimens, which were correctly identified and labelled. Each label showed the laboratory code, genus, species and locality. The samples are 10 years old.

Each specimen was examined as carefully as possible to avoid damage, fine-tipped forceps and histological needles were used to handle the specimens, and they were observed under a Ken-a-vision model T-22061 stereomicroscope at 20x and 40x views to ensure their identification.

Additionally, a diagnosis was made for the species T. metuendus to corroborate its presence in Bolivian territory, according to the diagnosis of the original description2,23.

Results

Table 1 presents the updated list of Tityus species for Bolivia, the name of the species, the authors who cited or described it in Bolivian territory and then the specimens present in the INLASA collection with their respective code.

Table 1 List of Bolivian Tityus 

Species Location Date of Update Present at INLASA Reference
Tityus argentinus Species for Villa Tunari and Chapare in Cochabamba, Buena Vista in Santa Cruz and in the Chaco of Chuquisaca. 2000, 2023 ILS-E72-82 Campeche, Santa cruz. 14
Tityus birabeni Describes this species for Villa Tunari, Cochabamba. 1955 13
Tityus bolivianus Describes this species for Tipuani, La Paz, Species for Tipuani. 1985, 2023 ILS-E221, ILS-E222, ILS-E223 From Tipuani, La Paz. 14,27
Tityus confluens Species for Villa Montes, Tarija, dry chaco of southern Bolivia. 2019 25,26,28
Tityus horacioi Citan y describen esta especie para San Mateo, Cochabamba. 2011 18
Tityus kaderkai Cites and describes this species for Rurre-nabaque-Beni. 2005 ILS-E 217 From San Joaquín, Beni. 17
Tityus metuendus Appointment for the Bolivian Amazon. 2023 ILS-E 37 Procedente de Pando. 23
Tityus proseni Cites and describes this species for Locotal, Cochabamba. 1954 12
Tityus sorataensis Cites and describes this species for Sorata, La Paz, this species is cited for Sorata, La Paz, this species is cited for the communities of Cheje and Quime, La Paz. 2021 ILS-E46-63 de Cheje, La Paz; ILS-E100-197 de Quime, La Paz. 11,14,29

Diagnosis: Female 85 mm in total length, dark reddish brown to black colouring along the body. Prosoma: Carapace granular with marked carinae. Pedipalp: well-marked carinae mobile and fixed finger with 17-18, 15-16 oblique rows of granulites respectively. Mesosoma: sternites and tergites granular with well-defined carinae. Combs: Number of pectinate teeth varies from 19 in females to 20-21 in males, median basal lamina dilated especially in females. Metasoma: granular with dorsal terminal spine in segments II-IV, carinae arrangement 10-8-8-8-8-8-5, segments IV and V darker, Segment IV slightly higher than segment V. Telson: with strongly curved aculeus, subaculear tooth with broad base and acute tip (conoid). Sexual dimorphism: Males have a thicker and higher pedipalp hand than females, females have a more dilated and rounded median basal lamina.

Tityus metuendus. Material examined 1 specimen ILS-E 37 From Pando (Figure 1).

Figure 1 a) dorsal view prosome and mesosome, b) ventral view prosome and mesosome, c) dorsal lateral view metasome. 

Discussion

The first study of scorpions of the genus Tityus in Bolivia was carried out by Kraepelin in 1895 describing T. bolivianus which was used as a reference species for the description of the Bolivianus Complex by the same author in 1911. From then on, several changes were made in the complex, initially adding species, then reducing them by synonymies with taxonomic works such as T. andianus and T. bocki, which after further revision were considered synonymies of T. argentinus14, reducing the number of Bolivian species. T. gasci is a species that was described for French Guiana by Lourenço in 1982 24, the same author in 1994 suggested the presence of the species for Bolivia. However, according to Lourenço16 he refuted the presence of T. confluens, T. gasci and T. metuendus for Bolivia using a potential distribution criterion in which their distribution would no longer reach Bolivia. In the case of T. confluens25 they reaffirmed the presence of this species for Bolivia. Finally, the case of T. metuendus15 cites the species, but requested confirmation. According to Lourenço16 in his book Scorpions of Brazil, in the section on the distribution of the species he no longer mentions Bolivia in its potential distribution. Now with the ILS-E 37 sample from INLASA, the presence of the species was confirmed for the department of Pando. However, due to the lack of latitude and longitude data, it is not known to which locality it belongs.

With the proposed subgenera of Tityus10 the Bolivian species would be distributed in the following subgenera and their respective species: (Archaeotityus): T. kaderkai17. (Atreus): T. metuendus23. (Tityus): T. argentinus26, T. birabeni13, T. bolivianus27, T. confluens26, T. horacioi18, T. proseni12, T. sorataensis11. The present work will lay the foundations for future research on the genus Tityus in Bolivia, with further compilation of information, as the list could be updated with the addition or removal of species based on taxonomic work.

One of the limitations of the study was the lack of samples of each species cited in this work, in addition to the fact that the samples in the INLASA collection did not have precise geographic data. However, the data present in all the samples were the date and department of origin, as was the case with sample ILS-E 37 of the species T. metuendus. While the other samples analyzed ILS-E: 72-82 T. argentinus, ILS-E: 221-223 T. bolivianus, ILS-E: 217 T. kaderkai, ILS-E: 46-63 and ILS-E: 100-197 T. sorataensis had additional community and collector data.

One of the species that should be prioritized is T. confluens, as this species is of medical interest and has been shown to be a danger to be taken into account due to its venom and its ease of adaptation to urban and intra-domiciliary environments26. T. birabeni and T. proseni also need to be found for a re-description, as well as to update the species data with the new morphological characteristics currently in use, given that in the case of these two species we only have samples from the original description and they have not been collected by any other researcher in 68 years.

Scorpions are a very little studied group in the country, most of the work carried out on the group was done by foreign researchers and the reference material is found in foreign museums. Some national collections, such as that of the LPI of INLASA, have a considerable collection, but even so, more research and work is needed in the group to enrich national and international knowledge about scorpions, especially of a group of medical interest in the region, such as the genus Tityus.

The list of Bolivian species of Tityus is updated, of which to date 9 are known: T. argentinus, T. birabeni , T. bolivianus, T. confluens, T. horacioi, T. kaderkai, T. metuendus, T. proseni and T. sorataensis. The presence of T. metuendus in Bolivia in the department of Pando is confirmed, and the geographical distribution of the species is extended. It allows us to know the species of the genus present in the national territory and opens the door to future research on the listed species. With the identification of the INLASA LPI samples, we already have national material of some species such as T. argentinus, T. bolivianus, T. kaderkai, T. sorataensis and T. metuendus. These can be used by other authors for new research work in other fields.

REFERENCES

1. Bechara W, Liria J. Morfometría geométrica en cinco especies de Buthidae y Scorpionidae (Arachnida: Scorpiones) de Venezuela. Rev Mex Biodiv 2012;83(2):421-31. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22201/ib.20078706e.2012.2.954Links ]

2. Almeida RB. Atlas of the species of Tityus C. L. Koch, 1836 (Scorpiones, Buthidae) in Brazil [tesis maestria]. [São Paulo]: Universidade de São Paulo;2010 [citado 26 de mayo de 2022]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.11606/D.41.2010.tde-09122010-110103Links ]

3. Avigliano E. Escorpiones de Argentina. 1ra ed. Vázquez Mazzini, editores. Zagier & Urruty Pubns (Bs As);2010. p. 1-64. [ Links ]

4. Lourenço WR. What do we know about some of the most conspicuous scorpion species of the genus Tityus? A historical approach. J Venom Anim Toxinas incl Trop Dis 2015;21:1-12. DOI: https://doi.og/10.1186/s40409-015-0016-9Links ]

5. Flores E. Escorpiones de la Familia Buthidae (Chelicerata: Scorpiones) de Colombia. Biota Colombiana 2001;2(1):25-30. [ Links ]

6. Mullen G, Stockwell S. Scorpions. Medical and Veterinary Entomology. New York: Academic Press; 2002. p. 411-23. [ Links ]

7. Álvarez Parma J, Palladino CM. Envenenamiento por escorpión en la Argentina. Arch Argent Pediatr 2010;108(2):161-7. [ Links ]

8. Polis GA. Ecology. In: Polis GA, editor. The Biology of Scorpions. Stanford: Stanford University Press;1990. p. 585-60. [ Links ]

9. Braga AR. Atlas das espécies de Tityus C.L. Koch, 1836 (Scorpiones, Buthidae) do Brasil [tesis doctoral]. São Paulo: Universidad de São Paulo; 2010 [citado 20 de mayo 2022]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.11606/D.41.2010.tde-09122010-110103Links ]

10. Lourenço WR. Une nouvelle proposition de découpage sous-générique du genre "Tityus" C.L. Koch, 1836 (Scorpiones, Buthidae). Bol SEA 2006;39:55-67.-. Koch, 1836 (Scorpiones, Buthidae). Bol SEA 2006;39:55-67. [ Links ]

11. Kraepelin K. Neue Beitrage zur Systematik der Gliederspinnen. Mitt. Naturh Mus Hamburg 1911;28:59-107. [ Links ]

12. Abalos JW. Descripción de una nueva especie de Tityus (Buthidae, Scorpiones). An Inst Med Reg (Tucumán) 1954;4(1):107-13. [ Links ]

13. Abalos JW. Tityus birabeni sp. n. de Bolivia (Buthidae, Scorpiones). An Inst Med Reg (Tucumán) 1955;4(2):223-30. [ Links ]

14. Lourenço WR, Maury EA. Contribution a la con-naissance y systematique des scorpions appartenant au "complexe" Tityus bolivianus Kraepe-lin, 1895 (Scorpiones, Buthidae). Rev Arachnol 1985;6(3):107-26. [ Links ]

15. Acosta LE, Ochoa JA. Lista de los escorpiones bolivianos (Chelicerata: Scorpiones), con notas sobre su distribución. Rev Soc Entomol Argent 2002;61(3-4):15-23. [ Links ]

16. Lourenço WR. Scorpions of Brazil. Musée National d´Histoire Naturelle. Paris : Les Editions de Ilt; 2002. p. 3-15, 50-112, 242-6. [ Links ]

17. Kovarik F. Nový druh stira Tityus kaderkai sp. n. v terariu. Akva Tera Fórum 2005;11:58-61. [ Links ]

18. Lourenço W, Leguin E. Une nouvelle espece de Tityus de Bolivie, appartenant au sous-genre Tityus et au groupe d'especes "Tityus bolivianus"' (scorpiones, Buthidae). Bol SEA 2011;49:103-7. [ Links ]

19. Francke OF. Escorpiones y escorpionismo en el Perú. -VI. Lista de especies y claves para identificar las familias y los géneros. Rev Perú Entomol 1977; 20(1):73-6. [ Links ]

20. González Sponga MA. Arácnidos de Venezuela. Redescripción de Tityus discrepans (Karsch, 1879) (Scorpionida: Buthidae). Mem Fund La Salle Cien Nat 2004;64(161-162):91-100. [ Links ]

21. Avigliano E. Scorpions of Argentina. Buenos Aires: Zagier & Urruty Pubns; 2011. [ Links ]

22. Toscano Gadea CA. Clave para la identificación de las especies de escorpiones de Uruguay. IN-OTEC 2012;(7):82-9. [ Links ]

23. Pocock RI. Report upon the scorpiones and pedipalpi obtained on the lower Amazons by Messrs E.E. Austen and F. Pickard-Cambridge during the trip of Mr. Siemens steamship 'Faraday.' Ann Mag Nat Hist 1897;19:357-68. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00222939708680549Links ]

24. Lourenço WR. La véritable identité de Tityus bahiensis (Perty 1834). Description de Tityus eick-stedtae n. sp. (Scorpiones, Buthidae). Rev Arachnol 1982;4(1-4):93-105. [ Links ]

25. Ojanguren-Affilastro AA, Bizzotto C, Lanari LC, Remes-Lenicov M, de Roodt AR. Presencia de Tityus confluens Borelli en la ciudad de Buenos Aires y expansión de la distribución de las especies de importancia médica de Tityus (Scorpiones; Buthidae) en la Argentina. Rev Mus Argent Cienc Nat 2019;21(1):101-12. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22179/REVMACN.21.638Links ]

26. Borelli A. Viaggio del Dott. Alfredo Borelli nella República Argentina en el Paraguay. XXIII. Scorpioni Boll Mus Zool Anat Comp Univ Torino 1899;14(336):1-6. [ Links ]

27. Kraepelin K. Nachtrag zu Theil I der Revision der Skorpione. Jahrbuch der Hamburgischen Wissen-schaftlichen Anstalten 1895;12(1894):73-96. [ Links ]

28. Maury EA. Escorpiofauna chaqueña. II. Tityus confluens Borelli 1899 (Buthidae). Physis C 1974;33(86):85-92. [ Links ]

29. Humboldt-Paputsachis C, Fernandez GP. Análisis morfológico y morfométrico de Tityus (Tityus) sorataensis Kraepelin 1911 (Escorpionida: Buthidae) de dos valles mesotérmicos andinos, Quime y Cheje, La Paz-Bolivia. J Selva Andina Res Soc 2021;12(1):3-20. DOI: https://doi.org/10.36610/j.jsars.2021.12010003Links ]

Source of funding This work was self-funded by the Immunoglobulin Production Laboratory of the National Institute of Health Laboratories (INLASA).

Conflicts of interest All samples used in this work belong to the collection of the Immunoglobulin Production Laboratory of the National Institute of Health Laboratories (INLASA), and do not generate conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgements To the General Executive Director of the National Institute of Health Laboratories (INLASA). Dr. Evelin Fortun for letting me work in her institution, Dr. David Duran and Dr. Aleida Nina for giving me access to the material, for their support and patience in the elaboration of the research.

Ethical considerations Each sample from the wet collection of the Immunoglobulin Production Laboratory was used with the utmost care, always maintaining the hygiene and integrity of the samples. No collections were made for this study.

Research limitations Lack of precise geographical data on latitude and longitude. Absence of physical samples of some species.

Editor's Note: Journal of the Selva Andina Research Society (JSARS) remains neutral with respect to jurisdictional claims published on maps and institutional affiliations, and all statements expressed in this article are those of the authors alone, and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, editors and reviewers. Any products that may be evaluated in this article or claims that may be made by their manufacturer are neither guaranteed nor endorsed by the publisher.

Article ID: 162/JSARS/2022

Received: November 01, 2022; Revised: December 01, 2022; Accepted: December 31, 2022

*Contact address: Ministry of Health and Sports. National Institute of Health Laboratories "Néstor Morales Villazón" INLASA. Immunoglobulin Production Laboratory. La Paz-Plurinational State of Bolivia. Rafael Zubieta Nº 1889, Miraflores. La Paz-Plurinational State of Bolivia. Casilla M-10019. Tel: +519 2 2226670. Ciro Humboldt-Paputsachis E-mail address:cirohumboldt@gmail.com

Creative Commons License Este es un artículo publicado en acceso abierto bajo una licencia Creative Commons